Due to the design goals listed in the previous section, I knew that
I needed to be looking at pro-sound drivers for this project. I also
knew that if one of my main goals was chest thumping bass, I
needed to try to use as large of a woofer as feasible. In discussing
with our resident pro-sound expert, a combination of 18" woofer,
8" mid, and 1" tweeter seemed to be an appropriate choice.
I’m going to change things up a bit and focus a little more on
the drivers that I chose for this project. I know many people only
use elements of these designs, or use one driver and change
another, so I figured that some more specific info about the
drivers would be helpful.
Hammer 18CLF: This surplus driver is a limited-supply item,
but is nearly identical to the new Eminence Definimax 4018LF
18” driver, so my description should hold true for both. They are
very powerful-looking 18" woofers, and feature a massive cast
aluminum frame, high-quality coated paper cone, nicely vented
motor structure, and copper shorting rings for reduced distortion.
Frequency-wise, this woofer has a smooth response, without
significant breakup peaks or other anomalies. It has a strong
response up through 200 or 300 Hz, where it begins to diminish
in output. Thanks to the shorting ring in the motor structure, the
bass and midbass is very clean and tight.
Based on my experiments and use of this driver, I would say that
it would be at its best when used in smaller vented cabinets with
slightly higher tuning frequencies than what I used in this design.
With my alignment, the low-end extension was impressive for
a PA speaker, but was missing a bit of the “snap” and “punch”
normally associated with output around 50 or 60 Hz. With a
smaller box, higher tuning alignment, four or eight of these
running from 40 -120 Hz would produce some killer bass output.
If you’re looking to add some “bass bins” to your PA rig or club,
these would be an excellent choice.
Hammer 8SLF: Once again, this surplus driver is of a limited
supply, but is interchangeable with the Eminence Beta-8A for
all intents and purposes. In my opinion, the Beta-8 is one of the
best all-around high-sensitivity 8" midbass/midrange drivers
available, and is a steal at its price point. While it doesn’t appear
to be anything special in terms of construction, it has the perfect
combination of cone, surround, spider, and dustcap to provide
very smooth and clear midrange without any harshness or
breakup peaks.
It is an open-backed driver, which means that it does require a
rear chamber if it is sharing an enclosure with a woofer. This gives
it the flexibility to be put in small sealed enclosure if it is being
used as a dedicated mid, but it can also be used in larger vented enclosures as more of a midbass driver. When using it in a small
sealed enclosure, it is critical to properly damp the rear chamber
to prevent rear-wave reflections from distorting the sound. In this
design, I was able to clearly see these reflections in my preliminary
measurements, and had to make sure I fully damped the rear
chamber with a combination of foam, fiberglass, and Acoustastuf.
All-in-all, this is a very versatile 8" driver, and would be a great
choice for any high-sensitivity application. I’ve even used it from
80 Hz to 2.5 kHz in a home theater surround-sound system,
where the high sensitivity provided an excellent theater-like
experience even with a modestly-powered receiver.
Eminence ASD1001S w/ Dayton H07E Waveguide: The
Eminence ASD1001S is a relative newcomer in pro sound high
frequency drivers, and features an unobtrusive appearance as
well as price. For a mere $30 you get a driver with a titanium
diaphragm, nice quality spring terminals, and high sensitivity.
On paper, the frequency response of this driver is not the
greatest, showing a rolloff between 5 kHz and 10 kHz, with some
extra zing up around 18 kHz. My measurements coincided well
with the Eminence supplied measurements, which is nice to
see. Eminence doesn’t publish this data, but it is in the distortion
domain where this driver really shines. Distortion is extremely
low down to around 2 kHz, and remains low throughout the entire
range. The high-frequency rolloff is actually a result of the driver
staying linear (where most similar drivers are full of breakup
peaks and ringing); this combined with the overall low distortion
makes for a very non-sibilant, easy-to-listen-to driver.
Since the ASD1001S is a driver only, it does need to be mated
with a lens of some sort for implementation into a design. I tested
many waveguides and horns as part of the design process before settling on the Dayton H07E. This waveguide provided
minimal disturbance of the natural response of the driver, while
providing good loading down to 2 kHz. Smaller horns could not
provide this low-end loading, while the larger horns tended to
disrupt the high-frequency response. This waveguide seems
to be an excellent choice for applications where high-fidelity is
paramount over high-sensitivity.